Reason for request
First listing
Summary of opinion
Favourable opinion for reimbursement for the adjunctive treatment of epileptic seizures associated with cyclin-dependent kinase-like 5 (CDKL5) deficiency disorder (CDD) in patients 2 to 17 years of age, only in the event of drug-resistant epilepsy.
Unfavourable opinion for reimbursement in the other situations covered by the MA indication.
Clinical Benefit
| Moderate |
The Committee deems that the clinical benefit of ZTALMY (ganaxolone) is moderate in the adjunctive treatment of epileptic seizures associated with cyclin-dependent kinase-like 5 (CDKL5) deficiency disorder (CDD) in patients 2 to 17 years of age, only in the event of drug-resistant epilepsy.
|
| Insufficient |
The Committee deems that the clinical benefit of ZTALMY (ganaxolone) is insufficient to justify public funding cover in the other MA situations.
|
Clinical Added Value
| no clinical added value |
Considering:
- demonstration of the superiority of ganaxolone compared to placebo, as adjunctive therapy, in a randomised, double-blind study, on a primary endpoint of variation in the frequency of major motor seizures in the short term (17 weeks), with a modest size effect (median difference of -27.08% in patients with a median number of 49 to 54 seizures per month at baseline), in a context of a high level of drug resistance,
- the substantial medical need to have access to alternatives, due to the limited alternatives in this rare disease,
but in view of:
- the absence of a demonstrated statistically significant difference compared to placebo for the percentage of patients presenting an at least 50% reduction in the number of seizures, a relevant ranked secondary endpoint,
- the absence of robust data on quality of life, which is particularly impacted in this disease,
- the absence of long-term efficacy and safety data for ganaxolone, in the context of a chronic disease,
the Committee considers that ZTALMY (ganaxolone) as adjunctive therapy provides no clinical added value (CAV V) in the treatment of drug-resistant seizures associated with cyclin-dependent kinase-like 5 (CDKL5) deficiency disorder (CDD) in patients 2 to 17 years of age.
|
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
NFf0sSvPujvjbTGF